The Belt Shoppe – Frequently Asked Questions
General Belt Questions
How do I determine my belt size?
Measure an existing belt from the fold where the buckle attaches to the hole you use most. If you don’t have a belt to measure, measure your pants waist size and add 2–3 inches for a comfortable fit. Choosing the right size ensures a proper long-term fit.
Do belts stretch over time?
Full-grain leather belts may soften slightly with wear, but quality leather does not stretch significantly. Proper sizing and allowing a short break-in period will keep your belt fitting comfortably for years.
Can I use my own buckle with your belts?
Yes! Many of our belts feature removable hardware like Chicago screws, allowing you to swap in your own buckle. Be sure to check the product description to confirm if the buckle is removable.
Leather Questions
Are your belts made from full-grain leather?
Yes. Most of our belts use full-grain leather, the strongest part of the hide. Full-grain leather maintains its natural fibers, providing maximum durability and a rich patina as it ages.
What makes Amish leather belts different?
Amish belts are handcrafted using traditional techniques and thick full-grain leather. These belts are built for durability, simplicity, and long-lasting wear, rather than mass production.
What makes Crazy Horse leather belts special?
Crazy Horse leather is full-grain leather treated with natural waxes, giving it a rugged, distressed look and pull-up effect. It’s strong, durable, and develops a unique patina over time.
Usage & Fit
Are your belts suitable for heavy-duty or work use?
Yes. Belts made from thicker, stiffer leather — especially widths of 1.50" or 1.75" — are excellent for heavy-duty work. They provide support for tools, everyday wear, and even concealed carry when specified.
Are your belts good for concealed carry?
Belts made from thick, full-grain leather with proper stiffness provide reliable support for concealed carry. A sturdy belt helps reduce sagging and improves comfort when carrying a holster.
Customization & Special Orders
Do you offer custom belts or personalization?
Currently, we focus on our catalog products and do not offer engraved personalization or fully custom belts. Local leatherworkers may be able to add custom engraving if desired.
Shipping, Returns & Policies
What is your return and exchange policy?
We no longer accept returns. We do accept exchanges within our policy period, as long as the belt is in new condition. Please visit our Returns and Exchanges page for complete details and instructions.
Do you ship internationally?
Yes! We ship worldwide. Shipping costs and times vary depending on the destination. Check the shipping options during checkout for details.
